VW took a lot of criticism when the mkiv GTI came out saying it just looked like any other Golf so this time they gave it its own identify with the black front grill, black side skirts which matched in with the rear valence. Now that people are colour coding them I think they are removing that identity and just making the car look like any other golf.
Don't get me wrong Steve I think your car looks superb, I just think it has lost a bit of the GTI sporty look that VW intended.
Although I think your car looks stunning, I do agree with a bit of what is being said here. VW were trying to recreate the early, sportier image they had with the MK1 and 2, which involved some red detailing and black plastic.
However, I dont agree that you have detracted your car away from that image, it just looks a more finished article. If I am correct, only the GTI has that grille, so the GTI moniker is still alive and well in your car, I only wish they had adopted the same principle with the MK4 and made it a REAL GTI.
I love the look mate, I always thought the plastic rear end was a bit much !!