The cam pulley for the fuel pump isn't turning when the engine turns over.
I was driving at about 60-65mph, there was a 'thud' and the engine shut down (symptoms exactly the same as when the fuel pump belt and tensioner let go a week earlier, right down to the fault code (low fuel pressure or something)).. pulled onto the grass verge and awaited recovery.
Got the rocker cover off earlier this evening and the cam is ok, not snapped. The pulley has about 5 to 10mm of movement in it.
Now here's what I don't get.. if the chain has snapped, sufficiently for the cam to not rotate, surely the pulley/cam should just spin without the constraints of the belt? If it's not spinning, the chain is still preventing it and turning the engine over would spin the cam/pulley too?
Does that make sense?
Is it safe to crank the engine a couple of times with the rocker cover off to see if the cam spins?
If I'm thinking right, what else could stop the fuel pump pulley/belt from spinning? This is potentially a £1500 question, the cost of supply and fit a replacement engine.
I did that before.. way before.. when I was trying to get the fuel pump off.. can't really do that now because the fuel pump belt isn't fitted and I cannot access the crank pulley.
oke as i thought it's not there, software is old... i need to update it... that said... from what i read the pump chain if snapped doesn't mess with the timing, it just means you need to remove what is in the way to replace it... and the parts aren't that expensive either decent priced replacement I found was 120 pounds...
oke as i thought it's not there, software is old... i need to update it... that said... from what i read the pump chain if snapped doesn't mess with the timing, it just means you need to remove what is in the way to replace it... and the parts aren't that expensive either decent priced replacement I found was 120 pounds...
The pump runs off a belt, not a chain, and isn’t the problem.
The problem is that the cam pulley that runs the pump belt doesn’t turn (which presumably means that cam doesn’t turn either).
Logic would suggest that either means the cam has snapped or one of the cam chains has snapped.
The cams look ok.
But if the chain to that cam has snapped to the point it no longer ran it, I should be able to turn it and it not feel like it’s turning the engine over, right?
Well I can’t.
Doing the chains on these is about £600 parts and 25 hours labour.
These are not my chains, my engine is still in the car…
As your thread title says "Anyone fancy a punt" so here's my punt!
Has a sheared woodruff key been ruled out? You say the engine turns over by hand and the cams haven't snapped and the pump not turning. Or is the pump pulley on a taper and the bolt has come loose?
My knowledge of this particular engine is very small so if you like you can overlook what I have mentioned.
The pump might have a woodruff key and since the pump isn't turning ( but the engine is from your explanation) it might be just that... here is a picture of a new one
Yeah i typed to fast in my previous reply I full well know the pump is ran of a belt.
If i'd have the same problem i'd take the fuel pump off and check to see if that is the problem.
Actually scrap that about the pump it might be a broken chain tensioner that is stopping the camshaft from moving... thing is, you can't just replace one part you'll need to replace the lot... but still cheaper than getting another engine. I highly doubt it is the chain that went to be fair but you'll only know what went f you tear it down and investigate.
The pump might have a woodruff key and since the pump isn't turning ( but the engine is from your explanation) it might be just that... here is a picture of a new one
Yeah i typed to fast in my previous reply I full well know the pump is ran of a belt.
If i'd have the same problem i'd take the fuel pump off and check to see if that is the problem.
Actually scrap that about the pump it might be a broken chain tensioner that is stopping the camshaft from moving... thing is, you can't just replace one part you'll need to replace the lot... but still cheaper than getting another engine. I highly doubt it is the chain that went to be fair but you'll only know what went f you tear it down and investigate.
It’s nothing to do with the pump, pump belt or pump belt tensioner.
This is all on the cam side.
Which is why I’m struggling.
There’s just not enough of the typical busted chain (and/or tensioner) symptoms for us to fully buy into that.
Replacing chains and tensioners is not cheaper than dropping another engine in… it’s about a grand dearer.
Problem with tearing it down is it requires removing the engine, which we can’t do.
Time and space is something we don’t have.
well if you won't diy than yes engine replacement is the cheapest option... I don't see any other thing that would stop one part from moving in there unless the cam that stopped moving is blocked by a piece of metal/plastic and in most cases it's metal that stops it from moving while the rest still moves. Looking at that picture of all the chains it can only be either a chain that is broken/ a tensioner/ a chain guide (most likely) or the whatever holds the cam-sprocket on the camshaft has sheared off and is now stopping it from turning... that said you would be able to turn it (until the valves hit the top of the pistons on that side)
The valves don’t hit the pistons… this is partly why I’m a little perplexed.
And… the cam (that doesn’t move) is still connected to the chain (well, it sounds like it anyway). But when the engine turns over the pulley doesn’t spin so the cam isn’t moving.
It’s not making sense to us.
And it’s not that I won’t diy, it’s simply not possible.
Chains from the crank to the cams, then there's a sprocket on the cam that drives the pump that'll be mounted externally to the chain covers?
What doesn't spin? Cam sprockets will be woodruff key'd or conical and torqued up. If the chain is intact the woodruff key is snapped or the bolt has lost tension. Then the sprocket will be similar story?
Chains from the crank to the cams, then there's a sprocket on the cam that drives the pump that'll be mounted externally to the chain covers?
What doesn't spin? Cam sprockets will be woodruff key'd or conical and torqued up. If the chain is intact the woodruff key is snapped or the bolt has lost tension. Then the sprocket will be similar story?
Cam chains are at the back, pulley on the front that drives the belt that drives the fuel pump.
I can’t check chains or tensioners without removing the engine which isn’t possible (I also don’t have the finances to spend on garage fault finding missions)
Pulley on the front doesn’t spin when the engine turns over.
Conical, not woodruff, on both fuel pump and cam pulley.
All bolts tight as f***, possibly even tighter than that - I had to get a 2ft bar on them to crack them off.
Nothing is slipping.
The cam (with the pulley) has about 5mm of back and forth movement (without the fuel pump belt attached).
So when you rotate the engine both cams rotate as expected? The pulley on the front (which will be conical to the nose of the cam) is slipping? But the cam is intact and rotating?
So when you rotate the engine both cams rotate as expected? The pulley on the front (which will be conical to the nose of the cam) is slipping? But the cam is intact and rotating?
I don’t know if both cams rotate, I can’t rotate the engine without cranking it on the key - no access to the bottom pulley (even my low entry jack is too thick to get under the car).
The cam is definitely intact, can’t attach the vid clip of the cam movement- I’ll get on my laptop and see if I can upload it to YouTube.
I know the cam pulley for the fuel pump doesn’t spin because Kirsty was in the car turning it over (on the key) while I was prising the fuel pump belt cover open enough for me to see the belt.
If you can take the lash out of both cams with your hand on that sprocket, there is no tension on the chain. It's either snapped, loose or something else.
So it looks like the crank drives the chain to the head, one cam runs through with a sprocket on the end which drives the pump. Internal meshed gears drives the other cam.
What I'm not getting, though, is why the drive for the fuel pump doesn't turn when the cam clearly has a chain still connected.... even though its a bit looser than it should be.
Think I'm just going to hunt for a low-ish mileage engine and get it swapped....
Whatever is actually wrong isn't going to be cheap and this is making me ill (I'm not even kidding)
Either that or sell this spares/repair and grab something cheap (again). Am rather fond of this A5 though.
When it's not broken.
I'd hunt for a replacement engine... and just replace than once the engine is out, instead of getting rid, i'd pull it apart to see what happened... that way you know next time how to sort it out plus you'll have a ton of spare parts .... I know you downsized so i hope you got enough space somewhere to store the old engine.
It’s not rotating it’s just moving about 5mm in each direction.
That’s as much as it moves (apparently there shouldn’t be any movement)
If I put a socket and long bar on it I could turn it over and it’d feel like there’s compression though. But it doesn’t turn when the engine turns on the key.
there must be some metal stuck somewhere... it's a head scratcher but i can't see any other reason for it not to turn it must be a piece of metal that blocks it... maybe it's sheered off from one of the 2 internal meshed gears.. either way unless the lot is taken apart you won't know....
This sounds plausible to me if not for the fact that when we try to start the car on the key it sound perfectly normal.
No odd noises, rattling, banging, grinding, crunching, nothing. Just an engine turning over.
Since you aren't in a position to pull it apart, I'd just source a replacement engine and take it from there... yeah you're right but in some cases you can get the engine without the turbos, starter and gearbox... so block with the head etc all timed up.
I'll look for the capa engine see what I can find for less than 1500...
Since you aren't in a position to pull it apart, I'd just source a replacement engine and take it from there... yeah you're right but in some cases you can get the engine without the turbos, starter and gearbox... so block with the head etc all timed up.
I'll look for the capa engine see what I can find for less than 1500...
There's a few on ebay, I've messaged most of them asking for mileage with some way of proving it for the cars history.
No point me buying something without proof or with high mileage, I may as well just do the chains on mine since I'd have to do them on the replacement as a precaution.
Well... no takers @ £1600 (remap and associated work was a grand, front suspension work just after I got it was £600 - £1600 leaves me about £5k down) so I guess I'm in the market for an engine
fix it sell it at full price... get a mk4 or mk5 r32 call it a day, both keep climbing in worth daily. the mk4 v6 4motion is just weaker version of the r32 anyway plus it lacks the nice upgrades the r32's have.
If I fix it I'm about £8k in the hole with this car.. I'd be lucky to get £3.5k if I sold it, most likely £3k.. on a good day, less if I want it gone quick.
If I let it go for a grand now I'd lose about the same amount as if I sold it for £3k after it's fixed.
than fix it and keep it... they are sleek looking stylish (...Billy Eilish) motorway mile munchers when they run good...sorry stupid song popped in my head
Took £1250 for it, going tomorrow.
Also have a few hundred quids of spares to try and flog too..
This year keeps kicking me and I've had enough.
And I still need another car, which I don't want to deal with because the last one went pop.
Got jobs to do on the octavia, which I don't have time for (rear door window runner thingy and door lock gubbins) and the Leon needs a ccm which I don't have the enthusiasm for.
Oh.. and the vectra is in the garage which kirsty has lost the key to and doesn't remember the number.
I considered getting that back on the road but, currently, we know where it is without actually knowing where it is.
I'm using the octavia as my daily, it's just annoying that there's something needs doing (that I have the parts for) and its not getting done..
Audi isn't going until Sunday now.. at least the buyer is keeping me updated.
well either you have it done or you wait until you got time off and feel like doing it... it's not a car doesn't run problem so just try and not get aggravated by it... once it's sorted it'll be solid without you getting your nickers in a twist
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Volkswagen Mark IV Forum
3.1M posts
106.3K members
Since 2002
A forum community dedicated to Volkswagen Mark 4 owners and enthusiasts in the UK. Come join the discussion about performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more for the Golf, Bora, Jetta, Touran, and Scirocco!