and the winner is russell,had both doors done under warranty,but the passenger door went again this week!,when the warranty repairs were done i was told that they had put the new ali parts in so that it would'nt happen again,so i went to the dealer who done the work today to buy the re-pair kit and do the work myself as they wanted ?170 to do it,the parts guy told me that you can only buy it as a regulator,which we all know is crap,so i left the dealer in question and drove 25miles to the same dealer but in another town and bought the kit for ?30!,as you can see the clips that had gone again were the good old crapstic oops plastic ones so icalled the dealer to be told that under warranty they will use the stocks of the old plastic ones to get rid of them, but in my eyes they are fitting the plastic ones on warranty work knowing that they will go again so next time the warranty will be out and they charge you the full wack for the ali re-pair kit